I have never had the occasion of filing a Second Appeal before any
SIC/
CIC.
But, in most of my First Appeals, I have successfully presented citations from various decisions of the
CIC or
SIC's (even if it does not pertain to the same state), in support of my arguments. No one has objected till now.
Besides, there are several decisions of the
CIC, wherein
CIC themselves have referred to some other earlier decision/arguments, in coming to a conclusion. If
CIC can do this, why can't you and me do the same ?
These decisions also show that in some cases, both appellants and respondents have cited previous decisions of the
CIC to support their arguments. There have been no observations from any IC against this practice.