RTI Happenings: No RTI on office inauguration function: Sebi

[akhilesh yadav]

No RTI on office inauguration function: Sebi

As Reported in Indianexpress.com on 22 July 2012
No RTI on office inauguration function: Sebi - Indian Express


In a strange RTI query, Sebi was asked for details of gate entry and exit records of persons and vehicles that visited its Mumbai head office around the time of its inauguration nearly six years ago, but the market regulator has declined to share most of the information.The RTI applicant subsequently approached the Appellate Authority of Sebi (Securities and Exchange Board of India) for details sought through RTI (Right To Information) Act, but its appeal has been dismissed there also. As per an Appellate Authority order, passed last week and available on Sebi's website, the RTI applicant had sought "date, day and time of the inauguration of Sebi Bhavan at BKC (Bandra Kurla Complex) Mumbai and by whom the inauguration took place and time period or duration of the said inauguration programme from start to end."In response to this query, Sebi only provided a copy of invitation card for the inauguration function.The appellant contended that the card did not show that when the inauguration programme ended and therefore, he has not got any answer or information in respect of his question.The Appellate Authority, however, ruled: "On perusal of response of respondent in totality I find that the respondent has furnished all the information that was available with Sebi and could not furnish what was not available."If the respondent could provide all the details that was available on the invitation card, there cannot be any other reason to withhold or deny information about the end time of the programme," the order said, while noting that Sebi cannot provide an information that was not available

[Sajib Nandi]

Sponsorer

'No RTI on office inauguration function'


Reported by Financialexpress.com on Jul 22, 2012
'No RTI on office inauguration function'

New Delhi: In a strange RTI query, Sebi was asked for details of gate entry and exit records of persons and vehicles that visited its Mumbai head office around the time of its inauguration nearly six years ago, but the market regulator has declined to share most of the information.

The RTI applicant subsequently approached the Appellate Authority of Sebi (Securities and Exchange Board of India) for details sought through RTI (Right To Information) Act, but its appeal has been dismissed there also. As per an Appellate Authority order, passed last week and available on Sebi's website, the RTI applicant had sought "date, day and time of the inauguration of Sebi Bhavan at BKC (Bandra Kurla Complex) Mumbai and by whom the inauguration took place and time period or duration of the said inauguration programme from start to end."

In response to this query, Sebi only provided a copy of invitation card for the inauguration function.

The appellant contended that the card did not show that when the inauguration programme ended and therefore, he has not got any answer or information in respect of his question.

The Appellate Authority, however, ruled: "On perusal of response of respondent in totality I find that the respondent has furnished all the information that was available with Sebi and could not furnish what was not available.

"If the respondent could provide all the details that was available on the invitation card, there cannot be any other reason to withhold or deny information about the end time of the programme," the order said, while noting that Sebi cannot provide an information that was not available.

"I, therefore, find that the respondent has not erred in its response as contended by the appellant," the order said.

The RTI application had also sought the list of guests, including chief guest, for the inauguration and "also gate entry and exit register or records of person and vehicles visited at Sebi Bhavan during the whole of October 2006". Sebi, however, replied that "the details sought by the appellant were not available with the concerned department.."

The appellant contended that "if the respondent (Sebi) has inauguration card, then why not the list of invitees is available to the concerned department in an era of computer storage or if the file was deleted then on which basis or standing order it is deleted or destroyed".

The appellant argued that Sebi should at least provide the government Vehicle entry and exit details for October 2006, specially before and during the inauguration. The appellate authority, however, ruled that Sebi had clearly replied it does not have the information sought by the RTI applicant and "if the information is not available with the respondent, the respondent cannot be obliged to provide such an information."