View Profile: Pradip Shah - RTI INDIA- Right to Information

Tab Content: All; Pradip Shah; Friends; Photos

Older Activity
Yesterday, 09:13 PM

karira replied to a thread Education loan in Non RTI Issues

This portal is only meant for discussing issues related to the RTI Act. You can try Big Helpers Thread Closed

see more

2 replies | 46 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:10 PM

karira replied to a thread RTI Request for information "WHY". in Ask for RTI Query

Just file a RTI application with the PIO of that office and ask for the inspection of the entire file(s) related to............................. (For every correspondence on a subject, a new file is opened or the letter goes into an existing file)

see more

5 replies | 166 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:07 PM

karira replied to a thread No penalty if a Complaint is filed under Sec 18 ? in Ask for RTI Query

Read the SC judgment carefully. Then go back to the SIC and ask him to show you where has the SC ordered that penalty cannot be imposed when entertaining a complaint under Sec 18 ? Cant they even read and interpret a SC judgment properly ? If they cant even do that, how are they writing and...

see more

8 replies | 226 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:01 PM

karira replied to a thread SIC Assam provide info after one year.. in RTI General Discussions

No other alternative. Activists in MP have done it. Activists in UP have done it. Earlier, activists in AP, Gujarat and Goa had also done it.

see more

9 replies | 248 view(s)
Yesterday, 08:57 PM

karira replied to a thread Is it necessary to Vist to the office for collect the information. in Ask for RTI Query

Dont write anything to the PIO. Just file that first appeal and send him a copy.

see more

9 replies | 163 view(s)
Yesterday, 08:55 PM

karira replied to a thread RTI for overcharging in parking lots in Ask for RTI Query

It is not necessary for you to attend the hearing. However, your chances of success during first appeal (or any appeal) increase dramatically if you appear in person. I would suggest, please attend and make a strong argument. Please read: ...

see more

5 replies | 241 view(s)
Yesterday, 08:51 PM

karira replied to a thread can the questions like WHY , HOW , are answered under RTI rules? in Ask for RTI Query

In general, if you are not satisfied with the information provided by the CPIO, it is better to file a first appeal. Under RTI, the application is to be filed with CPIO only and he is duty bound to respond to it.

see more

23 replies | 4850 view(s)
Yesterday, 08:48 PM

karira replied to a thread BCCI is a public authority. Need to amned the provisions in RTI General Discussions

So, someone has to build up a water tight case by categorising and putting a value to all elements and justify "substantially financed or controlled". No one has done that till now. There is a old thread on the BCCI issue running here: ...

see more

6 replies | 113 view(s)
Yesterday, 08:42 PM

karira replied to a thread IS RTI applicant a consumer as defined under Consumer Protection Act - See the details in this post. in RTI General Discussions

A good alternative (can be tried by someone) is to not ask for completion of service (ie provision of info) in the Consumer Fora. Just ask for compensation for deficiency of service. DCRDc Karur has given an order available here: Karur DCRDC compensation on 05 Apr 2013 - Downloads - RTI INDIA-...

see more

188 replies | 15099 view(s)
Yesterday, 08:42 PM

karira started a thread New File Added: Karur DCRDC compensation on 05 Apr 2013 in Appeals & decisions

Downloads: A new file has been added by karira: Karur DCRDC compensation on 05 Apr 2013 The Karur DCRDC has granted compensation to an RTI applicant for "deficiency of service". Order is dated 05 April 2013. Full order is attached to this post.

see more

0 replies | 14 view(s)
Yesterday, 08:33 PM

karira started a thread Follow the new Central RTI Rules strictly while submitting RTI second appeal to CIC in RTI General Discussions

Please follow the new Central RTI Rules strictly while submitting appeals to the CIC. They have started following the rules strictly. If you do not follow the rules, the second appeal is likely to be returned (after a considerable long gap of time) with any of the attached covering notes. ...

see more

0 replies | 11 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:58 AM

karira replied to a thread karnal club a registred societ headed by Deputy commissioner as president ....club say ...not covered under RTI in Ask for RTI Query

Please read: http://www.rtiindia.org/forum/59457-delhi-constitution-club-stonewalls-rti-queries-its-functioning.html http://www.rtiindia.org/forum/72452-rti-court-decision-pca-sutlej-club-under-rti.html...

see more

3 replies | 66 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:54 AM

karira replied to a thread RTI for pending income tax refund...... in Ask for RTI Query

Please read: http://www.rtiindia.org/forum/blogs/karira/326-rti-application-pending-refund.html

see more

1 replies | 48 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:52 AM

karira replied to a thread can I ask information from my GYATI (community) trust? in Ask for RTI Query

A charitable trust is not directly under RTI. However, you can get some information about the Trust by filing a RTI with the Charities Commissioner with whom the Trust is registered. It will be the Charities Commissioner of that state.

see more

1 replies | 19 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:49 AM

karira replied to a thread regarding date of birth in Non RTI Issues

This portal is only dedicated to discussing issues related to the RTI Act 2005. You will not get any answers here to general doubts and requests for help in non RTI related matters. Thread Closed

see more

1 replies | 28 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:49 AM

karira replied to a thread need help in Ask for RTI Query

First you have to check whether Barathidasan university is a private university or a Government University. RTI can only be applicable to a Government University or a deemed University.

see more

1 replies | 24 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:46 AM

karira replied to a thread Civil Services Mains 2012 exam in New Member Introduction

File a RTI with the PIO of UPSC and ask for certified copies of your evaluated answer sheet. You can file a RTI application with the PIO of UPSC. Details of PIO will be available on the website of the UPSC, under the "RTI" link. Or simply call UPSC and ask "Who is the PIO in your office under...

see more

1 replies | 33 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:44 AM

karira replied to a thread Education in Non RTI Issues

This portal is only dedicated to discussing issues related to the RTI Act 2005. You will not get any answers here to general doubts and requests for help in non RTI related matters. Thread Closed

see more

1 replies | 25 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:44 AM

karira replied to a thread Aicte rti in Ask for RTI Query

Yes they can transfer the RTI to AICTE since the information is with AICTE. Wait till 16/6 for the PIO of AICTE to provide you information.

see more

1 replies | 26 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:29 AM

karira replied to a thread Cic has dismissed my second appeal on supportless oral assurances of the respondent in Ask for RTI Query

Follow the same format as for a second appeal. Only difference will be that you title it as a "Complaint under Sec 18 of the RTI Act 2005". Do not pray for getting information. Just pray for penalty top be imposed under Sec 20(1) of the RTI Act 2005. Please Read Sec 20 of the RTI Act carefully...

see more

9 replies | 222 view(s)
05-23-2013, 09:06 PM

karira replied to a thread BCCI is a public authority. Need to amned the provisions in RTI General Discussions

IOA gets funding from the Government. BCCI does not.

see more

6 replies | 113 view(s)
05-23-2013, 09:04 PM

karira replied to a thread Is it necessary to Vist to the office for collect the information. in Ask for RTI Query

Two threads merged The reply of the PIO is totally incorrect as per the RTI Act. File a first appeal within 30 days of receiving the PIOs reply. The grounds will be: 1. There is no provision in the RTI Act for the PIOO to ask for ID proof of applicant (unless he is BPL and claiming...

see more

9 replies | 163 view(s)
05-23-2013, 08:50 PM

karira replied to a thread FAA of CIC: "Appellant can file many first appeals" in Appeals & decisions

The FAA of the CIC is correct, although he has not been able to explain clearly. Sec 19(1) simply means that every decision/order (or no decision) of the PIO can be appealed against to the FAA. The "an" that you highlighted, simply means that one appeal for every order/decision (or no...

see more

4 replies | 141 view(s)
05-23-2013, 09:39 AM

karira commented on blog entry Change or correction in the property card in mitesh.kuvariya

Visit the office that issued the property card and point out the mistake to them.

see more

1 replies | 23 view(s)
05-23-2013, 09:38 AM

karira commented on blog entry Income tax details of FIL in tigerdelhi

Please read some of the threads in the following search results: ...

see more

1 replies | 44 view(s)
05-23-2013, 09:37 AM

karira commented on blog entry How to get loan for business_I am BPL card holder in Anil Dabhi

This portal is only meant for discussing issues related to the RTI Act. You can try Big Helpers

see more

1 replies | 38 view(s)
05-23-2013, 09:32 AM

karira replied to a thread Private bank rti in Ask for RTI Query

Your post has been merged with another thread on the same topic/subject. Please read the full thread above and visit the links given in the various posts.

see more

5 replies | 273 view(s)
05-23-2013, 09:30 AM

karira replied to a thread New File Added: Guidelines for filing RTI Application online in RTI General Discussions

Two threads on the same topic/subject have been merged.

see more

32 replies | 1309 view(s)
05-23-2013, 09:21 AM

karira replied to a thread Cic has dismissed my second appeal on supportless oral assurances of the respondent in Ask for RTI Query

After the SC order re Sec 18 (in 2012), the Commission cannot order disclosure of information while disposing off complaints. It can only do so while disposing second appeals. (Probably that is why you are under the impression that Sec 18 was abolished - when no such thing has happened). You can...

see more

9 replies | 222 view(s)

More Activity

Pradip Shah Not too shy to talk

Mini Statistics

More 35 Friends

6 Groups

Join Groups 0 Permission Groups

Recent Visitors

21 Visitor Messages

Basic Information

About Pradip Shah

Personal Information

Statistics

Total Posts

Visitor Messages

Total Thanks

Downloads

General Information

Helpful Postings

35 Friends

Pradip Shah
Not too shy to talk