View Profile: souravsmile - RTI INDIA- Right to Information

Tab Content: All; souravsmile; Friends; Photos

Older Activity
Yesterday, 07:58 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread RTI application to PNB for details of recruitment in Ask for RTI Query

If your query remains unanswered or is not answered to the full , then it is denial of Information on that very particular query . The remedy is First Appeal . But in your case I find PIO has answered most of the queries , it may be considered that he meant to provide Information . The laps may...

see more

3 replies | 51 view(s)
Yesterday, 07:51 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread APIO appointment in Ask for RTI Query

If Information is supplied efficiently , then one may ignore such irregular procedure , otherwise PIO is the one who can decide the RTI Appl and supply the Information under his signature . But there is another aspect to it . In case anyone other than PIO deals with the RTI Appl directly , will he...

see more

6 replies | 78 view(s)
Yesterday, 07:33 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Municipal corporation in Ask for RTI Query

Besides continuing with RTI , contact a lawyer and if suggested so , serve a Notice u/s 80 CPC to Municipal Corp. followed by Writ Petition in High Court after 2-3 months if encroachment persists . Do not leave path of RTI along with , as it will create an avenue to communicate with MC during...

see more

3 replies | 25 view(s)
Yesterday, 07:19 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread about section 9 of RTI Act in Ask for RTI Query

The Copyright Act, 1957 protects original literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works and cinematograph films and sound recordings from unauthorized uses. Unlike the case with patents, copyright protects the expressions and not the ideas. There is no copyright in an idea. the copy righted...

see more

3 replies | 67 view(s)
Yesterday, 06:42 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Inspection of electronic records in Ask for RTI Query

Information on diskette can not be denied as every Computer has it , denial can be taken care of in Appeals . Demanding an Image of the whole HDD , unless requested specifically in RTI Appl , and every bit of data on it being out of purview of s.8 and 9 , is a bit too much to expect , and is...

see more

34 replies | 434 view(s)
Yesterday, 06:17 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Ethics and RTI in RTI General Discussions

Pune MC certainly makes a news , it has to be appreciated . Taurus has strong argument against the suggestion .

see more

7 replies | 82 view(s)
Yesterday, 01:12 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Ethics and RTI in RTI General Discussions

Sharad ji , thanks for your highly valuable input. Prasad ji , very flattering words . To be honest , I have faced some really discourteous too . I thanked the officer for the courtesy and returned . I did not react as I wanted to consider his suggestion and I would not discourage him if...

see more

7 replies | 82 view(s)
Yesterday, 10:26 AM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Inspection of electronic records in Ask for RTI Query

Never attach your own pendrive or Ext HDD to computers of any Public Authority . There is a chance that you may be blamed later for things like Infecting their system , data crash , data theft etc. Just ask for data on diskette .

see more

34 replies | 434 view(s)
Yesterday, 10:13 AM

dr.s.malhotra started a thread Ethics and RTI in RTI General Discussions

I am seeking opinions . I am not suggesting anything here . I have been believing that RTI Applications can either Investigative or Non-Investigative Recently I filed an RTI Appl for certain Information of latter type just to know how the Public Authority works , steps involved in that...

see more

7 replies | 82 view(s)
Yesterday, 09:46 AM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Inspection of electronic records in Ask for RTI Query

If you have not already made a request for copy of file on diskette , then file a fresh RTI Appl for the same .

see more

34 replies | 434 view(s)
06-18-2013, 08:13 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Inspection of electronic records in Ask for RTI Query

Yes , why not !

see more

34 replies | 434 view(s)
06-18-2013, 07:46 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Sec 18 or Sec 19 in Ask for RTI Query

I am not able to comprehend your above statement Sir . Plz elaborate . I did not consider whether it was pronounced before or after . I simply say the Judgment is silent on s.19(3) . I am not questioning concurrent use of s.18 and 19 , this is quite an old debate on this forum . Although I never...

see more

9 replies | 166 view(s)
06-18-2013, 07:04 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread i m working in Postal Department. my duty is to handle court cases of the department in Ask for RTI Query

Certified copies of Judicial Documents can be produced by NONE OTHER THAN COURT . So , obviously you can not give certified copied .

see more

5 replies | 96 view(s)
06-18-2013, 07:00 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread i m working in Postal Department. my duty is to handle court cases of the department in Ask for RTI Query

can you explain, Sir !

see more

5 replies | 96 view(s)
06-18-2013, 06:53 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Inspection of electronic records in Ask for RTI Query

the meta data is one great piece of forensic evidence in criminal cases .

see more

34 replies | 434 view(s)
06-18-2013, 01:54 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread jurisdiction for writ. in Ask for RTI Query

writ petition can be filed in HC with territorial jurisdiction of (1) or (2) .

see more

5 replies | 74 view(s)
06-18-2013, 01:51 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread i m working in Postal Department. my duty is to handle court cases of the department in Ask for RTI Query

Reply to your specific query : RTI Applicant has to be an Indian Citizen . He is not required to give reasons for seeking information . He may use the received information for any legitimate purpose .

see more

5 replies | 96 view(s)
06-18-2013, 01:47 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Role/powers of FAA for penalising the concerned Deptt./officer in Ask for RTI Query

Technically it will be FA u/s 19(1) , taking the ground of false and or misleading information , amongst others . In the facts of Appeal , mention the facts as known to you .

see more

5 replies | 99 view(s)
06-18-2013, 11:09 AM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread CIC recommends Disciplinary Action under Sec 20(2) against FAA in Appeals & decisions

I think it is a case of TYPING ERROR . The Order tends to have same effect on AA as the RTI sufferer may have wished . AA may have to approach the High Court for getting the Order quashed . What can not be done directly ...............

see more

6 replies | 289 view(s)
06-18-2013, 10:54 AM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Bank CCTV Footage in Ask for RTI Query

In your FA , request AA to direct PIO to secure data / recording till you have exhausted your Appeals / writ .

see more

14 replies | 191 view(s)
06-18-2013, 10:51 AM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Inspection of electronic records in Ask for RTI Query

I am afraid these things may not work if the Computer data is also fudged . The received hard copies will again show the same date as you have seen before . You need a soft copy of the file on the diskette with its meta data . When a digital file is created , it has its footprint , that is it...

see more

34 replies | 434 view(s)
06-18-2013, 10:41 AM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Answers Keys not provided under RTI Act in Ask for RTI Query

here is the CIC Order : http://www.rti.india.gov.in/cic_decisions/CIC_SG_A_2011_003062_17020_M_74829.pdf

see more

5 replies | 146 view(s)
06-18-2013, 10:23 AM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Court records under RTI in Ask for RTI Query

It is a Judicial Record none-the-less and hence Court Rules shall apply . RTI may not be helpful in view of various Court Orders in this respect .

see more

4 replies | 71 view(s)
06-17-2013, 11:12 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Role/powers of FAA for penalising the concerned Deptt./officer in Ask for RTI Query

1. The PIO is required to supply in form in which it exists . 2. PIO and AA are part of same Public Authority . If ever the AA has recommended any departmental action against PIO / APIO , such cases could be counted on fingers easily . AA is one weak link in RTI Act who either should not have...

see more

5 replies | 99 view(s)
06-17-2013, 11:01 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Sec 18 or Sec 19 in Ask for RTI Query

If you can get it done , the IC will do it .

see more

9 replies | 166 view(s)
06-17-2013, 08:25 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Where to file First Appeal? in Ask for RTI Query

Development Authority transferred records to MC . So there must be record of take-over of the records from DA to MC . So this is one point of investigation - when the record was transferred , what records were transferred from DA to MC . You may either Inspect the records or get documents on this...

see more

3 replies | 51 view(s)
06-17-2013, 08:07 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread need help to frame a query for this in Ask for RTI Query

I am afraid , I will stick to my reply . Let experts give their views on the matter .

see more

5 replies | 124 view(s)
06-17-2013, 08:05 PM

dr.s.malhotra replied to a thread Where should i submit the RTI appliaction for Land Issues in tamilnadu in Ask for RTI Query

I fail to agree with you somehow . It should not be difficult to get documents from case file . It appears to be a civil matter . Another way is to contact the private parties in the matter . Regarding RTI : See this web page :...

see more

3 replies | 50 view(s)

More Activity

souravsmile
Just Popping In

Mini Statistics

More 1 Friend

dr.s.malhotra

Recent Visitors

Basic Information

About souravsmile

Personal Information

Statistics

Total Posts

Total Thanks

Downloads

General Information

Helpful Postings

1 Friend

dr.s.malhotra

souravsmile Just Popping In

Mini Statistics

More 1 Friend

dr.s.malhotra

Recent Visitors

Basic Information

About souravsmile

Personal Information

Statistics

Total Posts

Total Thanks

Downloads

General Information

Helpful Postings

1 Friend

dr.s.malhotra

souravsmile
Just Popping In