As per interim order of SC, the process of recruiting must start immediately. The part, whether they will be from judicial bkgrnd or not, has been stayed and will be decided in it's final order.
...
Type: Posts; User: digal; Keyword(s):
As per interim order of SC, the process of recruiting must start immediately. The part, whether they will be from judicial bkgrnd or not, has been stayed and will be decided in it's final order.
...
The problem has become ubiquitous.
You can not solve this problem through RTI.
Let's wait for the Namit sharma case pending before Hon'ble SC. May be, in double benches with judicial background...
You can pray for penalty u/s 20(1). But, don't expect the same from the present ICs, unless a strong case for refusal/deemed refusal by PIO.
Penalty is a fixed rate, i.e Rupees Two hundred and...
The obligation to transfer the application to another PA u/s 6(3), lies on 1st Public Authority(not PIO), and after transfer, the applicant has to be informed.
It doesn't matter whether the 2nd PA...
Go for 1st Appeal.
It is not easy (at least till CIC level) to get marks of colleagues, unless proved for larger public interest.
The attachments at the following post contains different...
Recheck whether PIO & AA have really received your application/appeal or not. Do not miss the proof of your posts.
Raise this issue before SIC. Pray for punishment to PIO u/s 20(1) & (2);...
The reply is in the following thread that you have already started in this connection.
http://www.rtiindia.org/forum/112307-wrong-public-authority.html#post273016
if you know the address of the concerned authority, why don't you apply directly?
Else, post your queries(deleting the confidential parts, if you feel so)/requirement to get help from members.
...
Definitely an excellent initiative after compulsion.
But, does the Hon'ble IC to which shri Das himself attached, always pass Speaking Orders?
What can one construe by going through the order...
The asked information should be in material form:
The PIO is not supposed to speculate or create any information.
Suppose, if you will ask why Govt does not take any steps to control...
Pl go through the links & find the interesting replies. Officially we do not have a Father of Nation. And no official record for National holidays for 26th JAN, 15th AUG & 2nd OCT.
Had she been a...
Referring to Post#2 by ambrish ji ,
i have the following attached format, received through this forum.
Regards
R K Mishra.
Well known junior activist Aishwarya Parashar had put PMO in trouble asking the following information.
1)A query posted by a 10-year-old girl Aishwarya Parashar under the Right to Information...
Go for 2nd Appeal u/s 19(3), praying compensation u/s 19(8)(b),as PIO him/herself accepted the "weeding out" of the records. Send a copy to the corresponding PIO.
[weed outvb (tr, adverb) to...
The Delhi High Court in Arvind Kejriwal vs. CPIO(W.P. (C) 6614/2008 & CM APPL No. 12685/2008) considered that once the information seeker is provided information relating to a third party, it is no...
Dear Adarsh
I don't think there is any need to proceed further in this direction.
PIO has given the required reply as available in record.
Remember, PIO is not supposed to clean the city. He...
The Answer lies in Post #2 & 3.
Pl. Go through & act according to your requirement.
Regards
R K Mishra
1. If you have addressed To the Public Information Officer,.. then.. THE ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX – RANGE 14....., the application will be directed to the PIO.
2. Else, the fate of...
Comparing with the copy of 13 Sep decision, obtained through this forum, appears to be para-105.8 &105.9(instead of para-108.8 & 9 in the stay order).
However, there is no confusion that, except...
The esteemed order posted in Post #21(by avinash) is a replica of an earlier order by the same IC SG:
http://rti.india.gov.in/cic_decisions/CIC_SG_A_2011_000464_12432_M_56475.pdf
However, the...
It is not clear whether you are the PIO or one of the employees on which the information is sought.
With whom they are all bargaining?
How come they drag somebody to court by asking information...
@ jatinji
If i remember correctly, you had audio-recorded an earlier hearing, where IC ML threatened you to recommend for departmental action for asking information! He too observed that you filed...
These days, limit of 30 days for PIOs' reply, have been virtually increased to to endless wait(till IC orders for information). Thanks to the former bureaucrats selected as ICs!
1. Did you clearly...
Go through post#5
1.RTI query 16th june 11>2.1st Apeaal 3rd Aug 11>3. CIC order(!!) 21st Nov 11> 4.Not complied >5. 2nd Appeal 3rd Jan 12> 6. 2nd Appeal 3rd Sep 12.
I assume either #2 is a 2nd Appeal or u missed...
Let there be an earlier order as u mentioned. That is overruled by a series of later CIC decisions against DoPT.
If it comes under the same PA, this is the responsibility of CPIO to take...
If the information is not available with the PIO, s/he should have transferred your application u/s 5(4) within the same PA, and u/s 6(3) for a different PA with an intimation to you.
However, go...
From the low resolution attached jpg files, it seems the PA is a bank. So you need to appeal before CIC with all documents attached. Appeal should be precise and as per Appeal procedures 2012.
At...
Of course you can, provided the respondent is a Public Authority. Apply u/s 6(1) with a fee prescribed under rules (IPO/DD of Rupees 10/- for central Govt/PSUs) to PIO of the PA.
To know more, go...
For decision#1 & 2: May be both are direct complaints { it shall be the duty of the Central
Information Commission or State Information Commission, as the case may be, to receive
and inquire into a...
Yes, if asked under 6(1), a PIO is not supposed to provide the reasons for leave rejection, if d same is NOT in record, as he/she can not create information. S/he can only provide the reasons of RTI...
@ Rajneesh
For Misleading and False information, the ideal way was complaint u/s 18 (1)(e).
But, as PIO has replied (though deliberately false/misleading), Complaint at CIC will not...
@ R. Ganesan
Appeal again at CIC with a copy of the order, for noncompliance of his/her order mentioning 'Adjunct to appeal no xxxx'. (Complaint will not be beneficial). Pray for compensation +...
@vinaykala
What was the cic order no. and date of decision.
Appeal again at CIC with a copy of the order, for noncompliance of his/her order mentioning 'Adjunct to appeal no xxxx'. (Complaint...
Yes, you must send signed copy of all the documents including the printout of the complaint.
Very shortly:1. RTI application >information received /not received >1st Appeal ...
Grievance is different than RTI.
Grievance can not be redressed through RTI.
Similarly, Grievance redressal can not be a replacement for the functions of RTI.
If RTI would generate strained...
Section 3 of the Act:"Subject to the provisions of this Act, all citizens shall have the right to information." It includes the Public/Govt servants.
In context of Hon'ble SC decision(SLP...
Send your signed copy by the following address:
Central Information Commission
Room No. 326, 2nd Floor, "C" Wing
August Kranti Bhawan
Bhikaji cama Place
New Delhi-110 066
By the time your...
In the said case (SLP (Civil) No. 27734 of 2012) at SC, the applicant had sought mainly information for copies of all memos, show cause notices and censure/punishment awarded to the employee from...
@manishcho
Do not wait for RTI reply to send your parcel. You may get the rules from the indiapost site.
India Post | Mail Services | Parcel : I think you won't require to file RTI for the same...
@rajeshpatil
congratulations for the success! Now you got to know the abc of RTI.
There is nothing that will prohibit filing another RTI at SBI.
The address is available at the SBI site.
...
@ jayaram
As kariraji said, find out whether they hire as per rule or not. If not, you can object his presence at the time of hearing.
If yes, never mind, if your appeals has strong grounds,...
Whether your query is about the letter by Mr. S. Jaiswal? Then why doesn't Mr. Jaiswal himself file another RTI to know the status?
You may challenge at FAA u/s 19(1) on the ground of larger...
So far as ACR is concerned, it can be disclosed to the employee her/himself. (Centre of earth science Vs DR. MRS.ANSON SEBASTIAN, SCIENTIST WA.No. 2781 of 2009, Ernakulam HC.,| Dev Dutt .-vs-Union of...
Let us see the order. There is nothing that will prohibit you from writing.
For disciplinary action, SIC has the power to recommend u/s 20(2).
If Hon'ble IC has awarded punishment u/s...
I agree with ambrishji's post#2 with conditions.
As the enquiry is already over and there is nothing to hide about the facts (misdeeds of the applicant) to the applicant himself.
-u/s 4(1)(d),...
You can represent with an authorization of the appellant(RTI Rules, 2012; rule#12(2)). Do not try to record openly without permission of Hon'ble CIC.
They have a common format for sending a notice to respondent by appellant.
CIC Management 2007 had a mandatory provision on that. The same has been disapproved; So, no need to worry. That is not...
As per Hon'ble SC order, U/s 18(1) one can not get information.
The decision might have been challenged before HC.
File another RTI to know the status of the decision. If not challenged, file...
As reported by DNA India,
CBI claims exemption from disclosing corruption info under RTI - India - DNA
CBI claims exemption from disclosing corruption info under RTI Published: Monday, Feb...
As reported by DNA India CBI claims exemption from disclosing corruption info under RTI - India - DNA
CBI claims exemption from disclosing corruption info under RTI
Published: Monday, Feb...
Details of the branch and PIO is as follows:
-------------------------------------------------------
Bank Name:
State Bank Of India
...
One thing is not clear: and Whether you got information or not? Or you need same information free of cost?
However, ambrish ji's Post#2(Shah ji's Blog) will definitely work. My grievance...
I converted "RTI Rules 2012" to document, so that members will get help to copy statements/Rules therein for future reference:).
Attaching the converted document file
For consumer court, some other members may help you.
I would suggest you to go for 1st Appeal. To avoid further postal expense, you may call the PIO.
If you have grievance regarding service matters, you can't redress them through RTI.
However, if you want to know information regarding rules/procedures followed by your organization...
It depends on the Rules that is followed.
For central Govt./PSUs, DoPT has not specified about postal charges. So, postal charges must be excluded from fees.
But, there are some State Rules, by...
The best way is to go for 2nd Appeal, praying for the same grievance as you said.
The member who started this thread might have confused that, his thread has given us much valuable information regarding all other things except the center line : Exact procedures laid in RTI, for...
@ Rajan saab
Please see my post#10 and Prasad-ji's post#23.
Some of the 1st Appeals, that i helped the applicants, were heard too.
If you need i will attach proof (not scanned yet) that,...
I tried with all the three browsers; the same result.
Other attachments in other threads are opening correctly. May be some problem with my system, provided all other members do not face the same.
Attachment at Post#1 showing "Invalid Attachment specified".
@ Sunil-ji
Kindly mention the Provision/Rules followed by FAAs, to prove that "mandatory in RTI" is universal & to cease this esteemed argument once & for all.
There is a lot of difference...
Both Sunil-ji & Sarbajit-ji are very well learned & say according to their experience and immense knowledge in the field.
But, one thing is clear that there is nothing "mandatory" to hear the...
May not be entirely, but for all most all.
Yes, few Appeals; but all most all Complaints end with a remand or direction for information without a procedure u/s 18(2/3) : Thereby condoning PIO,...
Gone are those golden oldy days.
The fact is, sec 18 has become a showpiece & the golden lines inside quote, only charms the reader. Thanks to our former bureaucrats, who got post retirement...
In your Post#3, you were .
Still, an application has been fed to you in post#12.
I'm sure this application in post#14 will have a zero effect(some unsatisfactory reply may come).
Pl. take...
Technically you may go for 1st appeal. But, it will be more prudent if Mithu De redrafts and applies again with a correct IPO/DD as said.
However, as per your version, Mithu De had applied for...
I have gone through the handwritten RTI application(with difficulty) & the reply by PIO.
Had the application been a printed one, i would have read all the queries.
One thing is clear to me>...
क्या सरकार, सुऊप्योग के बारे में पता नेहिं लगाएगि?
सर्कार को सुऊप्योग बारे में भि पब्लीकको बोलना चहिए
आर के मिश्रा
It seems they are transferring u/s 6(3), by informing you about each transfer.
As i told,, under the same PA, the PIO should have collected the information u/s 5(4) & should supply the same within...
Apply u/s 6(1)to the corresponding PIO for a certified copy of the same. S/he may request for inspection too.
There are several decisions FOR and AGAINST (without disclosing the identity of the...
The resolution of the .jpg attachment is too poor (<50KB)to read. I tried my best to construe but failed. Pl. attach a .pdf scan or of bit high resolution JPEG image.
I will be happy to help you.
Did he apply to the same PIO (Public Information Officer) of the same PA(Public Authority)?
If Yes, during hearing at FAA, he may inform about the dept concerned. If no, request FAA to direct PIO...
As it comes under the same PA, this is the responsibility of SPIO to take help(transfer and receive reply) of the Superintending engineer u/s 5(4), and supply the information by himself.
...
Conforms with the order in my post #6.
Of course not, but not in first go(mostly). There are several cases which are not discussed(at least till CIC's decission).
And with this case, PIOs & AAs would prefer not to reply at all. Let...
I helped several citizens to file RTI. ALL including mine(min- 3queries max-10queries), never terminated before 1st Appeal. Yes, one of my application, after persuasion through 1st Appeal, was...
As the matter was different, I didn't want to prolong on the issue; so i didn't mention the outcome.
You are very much correct!
As you are interested & for the benefit of other members, i am...
yes.
Yes.
In addition to reply by karira-ji and depends on the information.
If the information provided to "B" is "personal" in nature, & that is only related to him, "A" may not...
As Posted by Former IC Shri S Gandhi in his FB Account.
https://www.facebook.com/shailesh.gandhi.16/posts/473449089388989
[I shudder at the frivolity of this unsubstantiated argument.
of...
No, entire bureaucracy can't be blamed. I think you didn't go through the links. What annoys us, is the process by which the ICs are selected. The bureaucrats (chaheta of Political bosses) whose duty...
This is the reason, i , along with karira-ji, several other members & media strongly object the inclusion of former bureaucrats as ICs. The result is obvious and open to all.
The series of...
How did u come to know the payable "name"? Their sites (http://www.agwb.cag.gov.in/html/Ag%28RW&LBA%29/RTIact2005.html or http://www.agwb.cag.gov.in/html/prag/RTI_Act2005.html ) do not reveal any...
As advised by Prasad-ji and karira-ji, do mention " life and liberty " in the heading.
Take care.
I had mentioned the above concerns in my grievance itself(attachment of post#1).
To establish the authenticity of reply by FAA, i am attaching a copy of the same.
Yes, i visited; I was fortunate enough to miss that scene, as he was on leave! But, i got good help from some of his subordinates.
“NON-COMPLIANCE OF FAA ORDER IS REASONABLE”: FAA of CIC himself!
Dear Members,
1. For a series of earlier lackadaisical actions at CIC (IC MLS registry), I had filed RTI at CIC to enquire about...
The later, to whom that has been forwarded.
By acknowledging you, u/s 6(3) , if they have transferred to different PA, the PIO has done as per the ACT.
Ans: There is nothing like CIC of west bengal(if not Chief IC). That can only be...
All that i was helping u is about Appeal/complaint to Central Information Commission (CIC). You will never get status of your RTI application (to University)in the link provided. Pl. go through the...
Mention the date & name by which u appealed. Members may help u to find out.
u can do it yourself, by permutation n combination of short forms of the name actually sent, in diary(letter) selection.
90 days is the maximum limit for 2nd Appeal. You need not have to wait till the limit.
Go through Time limits specified in the RTI Act - Guide to know about time limits.
The receipt and track...
As i said,
Why should the application go through accounts department?
If you can, file another RTI to know the procedure & under what rule they process a letter to the PIO.
The request for...
Filled; if required, i'll b pleased to help again.
It is calculated on the date received by PIO- if it is addressed to the PIO.
However, when a PA receives a letter, it should hand over the letter immediately and should follow as per "Manual of...
Just try the following trick, envisaging it may fail.
File another RTI by some other name (your friend/relative)
Ask "Number of applicants applied for passport(s) by the following address";...
In a similar situation, Hon'ble Justice of Calcutta HC was annoyed by the OPEN END SYSTEM of commission's decision & had ordered (attached) to decide within 45 days.
" ......The provisions of the...
As reported by The Times Of India, Pratibha Patil spent Rs 18 crore on her last trip as President, RTI query reveals - The Times of India
Pratibha Patil spent Rs 18 crore on her last trip as...
There is nothing wrong in applying for the copy. Most PIOs are not aware of the current situation. You may be lucky to receive the same.
With the recent developments{decision of SLP(Civil) No....
