The issue is still CIC returning such second appeals received in post for want of identity.
The on line procedure was not introduced NOW but three years back and the teething problems were reported several times in the forum.
In view of the same, experts advised members to prefer traditional mode of RTI correspondence through post.
the CIC second appeal format did not ask for any identity proof they only ask a copy of orginal RTI application, its reply by CPIO, first appeal copy and its reply and proof of dispatch but no where there is a separate provision regarding identity. if any doubt then I will upload the format.
Members who visit once in a blue moon, interested in sharing their knowledge, for replying on closed queries, or answering a query raised 3 years back, should read the earlier replies and answer. When members posted copies of such 'Return memos" several times, then explaining the documents to be enclosed for second appeal appears not proper.