Topic Identifier

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 18

Thread: CCTV footage and IT Act

  1. CCTV footage and IT Act


    Sir,

    Inresponse to RTI application seeking CCTV footage at Tehsildar's office,PIO has stated that CCTV footage contains images and data of third party people present at Taluk Office.Above all he has stated that Information Technology Act has prohibited the sharing of CCTV footage



  2. #2

    Re: CCTV footage and IT Act


    cic in one order has said that one has to prove his/her point as to why CCTV footage is needed
    one such reason is corruption, but it has to proven by rti applicant
    file another rtiapplication and ask for section/sub section number of IT act under which CCTV footage is denied
    also a prepare rti application ask for queris two follow section 11 of RTI act on third party

  3. Re: CCTV footage and IT Act


    Ultimately, what ever was stipulated as information under RTI Act, and CCTV footage is a Public record. If any PIO states that it is third party information, he has to follow stipulations under Sec.11 and obtain their comments. Without invoking Sec.11, denial mentioning some other act is not proper. The denial should always be under Sec.8 sub sections alone and not any internal guidelines or other Acts.

    Go for first appeal and escalate this to information commission, and get a good decision once for all.
    I also suggest for filing of RTI application seeking such extract of IT stipulations that CCTV footage should not be provided under RTI Act.
    Information solicited:
    1)Please provide certified copy of extract in Information Technology Act section/stipulation that has prohibited the sharing of CCTV footage, under RTI Act.
    (Sharing has several meanings like continuous coverage to others, circulating on regular basis etc)
    2.Please provide such section under RTI Act that states that providing CCTV footage as denial and such denial without justification and without invoking Sec.11 of RTI Act.

    This should be clarified by a full bench CIC decision to avoid such interpretations by individual PIOs and DOPT.
    Those who wanted to make a vigorous follow up can file RTI Application to DOPT CPIO and seek such information as record.
    Information solicited:
    1)Please provide existing guidelines/stipulations/OMs that state on providing of CC TV footage to individual applicants by Public authorities.
    2)Please provide whether there is any inconsistency in Information technology Act that bars Public Authorities in CCTV footage under RTI Act.
    3.Please provide number of RTI applications received by DOPT seeking such information and response by CPIO, DOPT denying such footage.
    4.Please provide number of letters received seeking guidance on such providing of CCTV footage by any Public authorities and copy of such response from DOPT to that Public authority.
    Last edited by G.L.N. Prasad; 05-10-17 at 10:43 PM.

  4. Re: CCTV footage and IT Act



    Sir,

    Filed RTI with DOPT as per your guidelines.Even IC's are not clear about classification of CCTV footage Data.In one of the hearing at SIC,the IC stated that miscreants may misuse CCTV footage containing images of lady staff at work and public present at their office

  5. Re: CCTV footage and IT Act


    Every PIO comes out with such apprehensions for not providing information, but mere apprehensions are not justifications. Once the purpose is known, no one can deny information.

  6. #6
    Posts
    44,647
    Name:
    C J Karira
    Blog Entries
    9
    Rep Power
    555

    Re: CCTV footage and IT Act


    Quote Originally Posted by rtipatrol View Post
    Above all he has stated that Information Technology Act has prohibited the sharing of CCTV footage
    Please read Sec 22 of the RTI Act 2005:

    22 The provisions of this Act shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in the Official Secrets Act, 1923, and any other law for the time being in force or in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law other than this Act.
    Twitter: @cjkarira

  7. Re: CCTV footage and IT Act


    As I understand ("any other law for the time being in force') the stipulations do not state about future laws and each PIO interprets this in his own way.

  8. #8
    Posts
    44,647
    Name:
    C J Karira
    Blog Entries
    9
    Rep Power
    555

    Re: CCTV footage and IT Act


    What is the meaning of "any other law for time being in force" ?


    This question was answered by the Hon'ble Madras High Court.

    Madras High Court
    J.Parthiban vs State Of Tamil Nadu, Rep.By on 27 March, 2008

    THE HONOURABLE MR.A.P.SHAH, THE CHIEF JUSTICE
    AND
    THE HONOURABLE MRS.JUSTICE PRABHA SRIDEVAN

    W.P.Nos.36423, 30273, 33336, 34120, 36968,
    37018, 37026, 37876, 37071, 37757, 37630, 37357
    to 37359 of 2007,

    “ Laws for the time being in force” - The phraseology “ laws for the time being in force” would necessarily mean laws in force from time-to-time and not laws in force only at a fixed point of time. The expression “for the time being” denotes time indefinite and refers to indefinite state of facts which will arise in future and which may vary from time-to-time.


    =============

    It is also not possible to accept the submission that the expression ''for the time being in force'' will have a nexus with the date of enactment of the Airports Authority of India Act. The expression ''for the time being in force'' merely implies that whenever the question of acquiring the land for the Airport Authority arises, the relevant corresponding laws of acquisition in force at that time can be resorted to. This is the clear thrust of section 19. Its scope and ambit cannot be circumscribed and frozen only to the point of time in the year 1994, when the Airports Authority of India Act was enacted. If such was the intention of the Parliament in framing Section 19, Section 19 would have employed a different phraseology, namely, ''laws at present in force'' instead of the phraseology ''laws for the time being in force". The phraseology ''laws for the time being in force" would necessarily mean laws in force from time to time and not laws in force only at a fixed point of time, i.e. the date on which the Airports Authority of India Act was enacted. The expression ''for the time being" denotes time indefinite and refers to indefinite state of facts which will arise in future and which may vary from time to time.

    ==============

    I also had to search and understand this because one IC in APIC - in the first batch of ICs - interpreted it as all those laws which were in force at the time of the enactment of the RTI Act 2005 !!
    Twitter: @cjkarira

  9. Re: CCTV footage and IT Act


    Sir,
    I've an hearing at SIC regarding the CCTV footage .Earlier PIO has stated that that Information Technology Act has prohibited the sharing of CCTV footage and it's third party information.

    The hearing is scheduled on 11.10.2017 and today PIO has posted an additional reply stating that CCTV camera's are not working and it's under repair for the last 6 months.

    Lot of discrepancies in the reply.

  10. Re: CCTV footage and IT Act


    File fresh application and seek information as follows:
    Information solicited:
    1)Please provide the material facts on record as certified copies that disclose that CCTVs are not functioning and under repair from 6 months.
    2)Please provide the copy of letter addressed to higher officials/Maintenance company complaining about malfunctioning, copies of all letters made for follow up to keep the CCTVs functioning.
    3.Please provide copy of the bill/expenses disclosing the costs incurred and present status.
    4)Please provide the date of installation, the specific dates on which CCTV failed to function, the dates on which the repairs were made, and the days in which CCTV functioned properly.
    5)Please provide a copy of circular/directive/order/notification that states about maintenance of CCTV cameras and trouble shooting exercises, follow up etc.
    6)Please provide the name of manufacturer, total costs for such coverage with copies of such bill for that expenditure.

    As far as present hearing is concerned parties can not approbate and reprobate and take different stand as per convenience and this disclose the deliberate and malafide intentions of the PIO. File written arguments well in advance through mail and through post.

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast


About RTI INDIA

    RTI INDIA: Invoking Your Rights. We provide easy ways to request, analyze & share Government documents by use of Right to Information and by way of community support.

Follow us on

Twitter Facebook Apple App Store Google Play for Android