If the information is about one or two selected candidates it may be supplied because after selection as a govt servant such personal data becomes matters of public record. But if someone asks for information pertaining to large number of candidates then the PA may justifiably take the plea of disproportionately diverting the resources and deny it. In this case it appears to be so. That is why the PA has offered to show the files. That is fair enough.
› Find content similar to: Is Information on application form on priscribed format for a post personal document