Topic Identifier

Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: Mere mention of corruption can`t bring intelligence under RTI

  1. #1
    C J Karira
    Blog Entries
    Rep Power

    Mere mention of corruption can`t bring intelligence under RTI

    As reported by Zee News - Mere mention of corruption can`t bring intelligence under RTI
    from Bureau Report

    Mere mention of corruption can`t bring intelligence under RTI

    New Delhi, Jan 13: A mere allegation of corruption not backed by credible evidence would not be sufficient to direct the country`s intelligence organisations to reveal information under the RTI Act, the Central Information Commission (CIC) has held.

    The right to information law that has categorically immunised certain security and intelligence organisations from disclosure of information is specific that in cases of alleged corruption or human rights violations against them, they could be asked to open up.

    In an apparent safeguard for such bodies, as listed in schedule two of the RTI Act, the CIC has held that if allegations of corruption were to be made out against them, credible evidence needs to be adduced in that regard.

    "Mere mention of corruption would not amount to a full-fledged allegation, unless there was re-reinforcing evidence. An allegation of corruption cannot be lightly made," information commissioner A N Tiwari said in a recent order.

    The order came in respect of an application of Ludhiana resident S P Goyal, who had sought from the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) examination of documents pertaining to its investigation of financial fraud against his company.

    While DRI, an economic intelligence organ under the finance ministry, is exempted from disclosure of information, Goyal cast doubts on DRI`s probe against his company since 1990, while seeking that the information be granted to him for reasons of a pervasive corruption in the conduct of the investigating officers.

    Contesting the allegations, the DRI said Goyal, who was at the receiving end of the probe, raised the corruption charges to distract its investigative action.

    It also refuted Goyal`s plea that in 1993, an inquiry was also done to look into allegations of irregularities against one of its investigating teams and said such an inquiry showed the allegations as "baseless".

    The commission, which found credence in the submissions of the investigative body, said, "when such allegations are made by a party, who is an object of investigation for tax and duty evasion and for other unlawful acts, it becomes tainted by personal motive and loses credibility.

  2. Re: Mere mention of corruption can`t bring intelligence under RTI

    Thats A Very Good Post Karira

    But To Bring Intelligence Under Rti Would Always Be Debatable

    In Fact As Per Ipc Even The Supreme Court Can Not Ask The Source Of Information From Intelligence And This Is Striking

    Any Way Its Some Where Good Also

    Or May Be Neutral As Intelligence Agencies Are Not Even Given Power To Arrest And Here The Things Are Balanced


    RTI INDIA: Invoking Your Rights. We provide easy ways to request, analyze & share Government documents by use of Right to Information and by way of community support.

Follow us on

Twitter Facebook Apple App Store Google Play for Android